**‘Benefits India’: Russian Expert Backs RD-93 Engines Sale to Pakistan**

*By Snehil Singh | Oct 06, 2025, 03:45 PM*

A recent report on the sale of Russian RD-93 engines to Pakistan for its JF-17 aircraft has stirred significant debate. However, a Russian defense expert has come forward to defend the deal, suggesting it could actually benefit India in unexpected ways.

**Strategic Insight from Russia**

Pyotr Topychkanov, head of the Section on New Challenges in South and Southeast Asia at Moscow’s Primakov Institute, emphasized that the reported transaction highlights China and Pakistan’s continued reliance on Russian technology.

According to Topychkanov, “Firstly, it shows that China and Pakistan haven’t yet managed to replace the Russian-origin engine. Secondly, the new aircraft will be familiar and predictable to India, especially since they share the same engine and India observed the JF-17’s operational use during the May 2025 crisis (Operation Sindoor).”

He argued that this predictability could offer India a strategic advantage in anticipating JF-17 capabilities given the shared engine technology.

**Conflicting Reports from Moscow**

Despite these assertions, another senior Russian source denied any confirmation of such a deal. In a conversation with WION, the insider called the reports illogical for serious observers monitoring India-Russia defense relations.

The source also suggested that these rumors might be driven by ulterior motives, potentially aiming to undermine the promising cooperation ahead of upcoming high-level engagements between the countries.

**Political Controversy in India**

The alleged engine sale has sparked political backlash in India. The opposition Congress party has heavily criticized Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government for allegedly allowing Russia to supply advanced RD-93 engines to Pakistan.

Congress general secretary Jairam Ramesh questioned why Russia would provide military support to Pakistan while India continues to purchase S-400 missile systems and negotiate for Su-57 stealth fighters from Moscow. He condemned the government for what he described as a lack of vigilance in safeguarding India’s strategic interests.

**BJP Stands Firm**

In response, the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) defended the Modi government against these allegations, labeling the reports as “reckless information warfare.”

Amit Malviya, head of BJP’s IT cell, cited a report that included Russia’s clarification on the matter. He accused Ramesh of spreading unsubstantiated claims on social media based on content from a website known for pro-Pakistan propaganda.

—

The debate over the RD-93 engine sale continues to fuel discussions on India-Russia-Pakistan defense dynamics, highlighting the complex nature of geopolitical alliances and regional security concerns.
https://www.newsbytesapp.com/news/world/russian-expert-defends-rd-93-sale-to-pakistan/story

**‘Benefits India’: Russian Expert Backs RD-93 Engines Sale to Pakistan**

*By Snehil Singh | October 6, 2025, 3:45 PM*

A recent report about Russia supplying RD-93 engines to Pakistan for its JF-17 aircraft has sparked intense debate. However, a Russian defense expert has come forward defending the move, suggesting it could actually benefit India in unexpected ways.

**Strategic Insight from Russia**

Pyotr Topychkanov, head of the Section on New Challenges in South and Southeast Asia at Moscow’s Primakov Institute, shed light on the potential strategic implications of the deal. According to him, if the sale is indeed going ahead, it reveals an important dynamic — China and Pakistan remain dependent on Russian technology despite efforts to diversify.

Topychkanov explained, “Firstly, it shows that China and Pakistan haven’t yet managed to replace the Russian-origin engine. Secondly, the new aircraft will be familiar and predictable to India, especially since they share the same engine. India also observed the JF-17’s operational use during the May 2025 crisis (Operation Sindoor).”

This familiarity could give India a tactical advantage by making the behavior and performance of Pakistan’s JF-17 fleet more predictable in combat scenarios.

**Denial from Another Russian Source**

Despite Topychkanov’s comments, a senior Russian insider has denied any official confirmation of the RD-93 engine supply to Pakistan. Speaking exclusively to WION, the source called the rumors “illogical” and suggested they might be attempts to disrupt growing ties between Russia and India, especially in light of upcoming high-level engagements.

**Political Fallout in India**

The alleged deal has also ignited political controversy domestically. The Indian National Congress party has strongly criticized Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government for failing to prevent Russia from supporting Pakistan militarily.

Congress general secretary Jairam Ramesh questioned the logic behind Russia supplying advanced engines to Pakistan while India continues to procure Russian defense systems like the S-400 missile system and negotiates for Su-57 stealth fighters.

**BJP’s Defense of the Government**

The ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) has dismissed the allegations as baseless and part of a “reckless information warfare” campaign. Amit Malviya, BJP’s IT cell head, referenced Russia’s clarification on the matter and accused Ramesh of spreading misinformation based on reports from sources with a known pro-Pakistan bias.

**Conclusion**

While the controversy continues, the discourse highlights the complex interplay of defense diplomacy and strategic calculations in South Asia. Whether or not the RD-93 engines are being supplied to Pakistan, the debate underscores the sensitivity surrounding military technology transfers and the geopolitical ramifications for the region.
https://www.newsbytesapp.com/news/world/russian-expert-defends-rd-93-sale-to-pakistan/story

**‘Benefits India’: Russian Expert Supports Reported Sale of RD-93 Engines to Pakistan**

*By Snehil Singh | Oct 06, 2025, 3:45 PM*

A recent report about Russia potentially supplying RD-93 engines to Pakistan for its JF-17 fighter aircraft has sparked significant discussion. While the news has caused controversy in India, a Russian defense expert asserts that such a deal could actually offer strategic benefits to India.

**Russian Expert Highlights Strategic Advantage**

Pyotr Topychkanov, head of the Section on New Challenges in South and Southeast Asia at Moscow’s Primakov Institute, defended the reported sale. He emphasized that if true, the deal underscores China and Pakistan’s continued dependence on Russian technology.

Topychkanov explained that this dependence works in India’s favor by making the JF-17 aircraft more predictable. “Firstly, it shows that China and Pakistan haven’t yet managed to replace the Russian-origin engine. Secondly, the new aircraft will be familiar and predictable to India, especially since they share the same engine and India observed the JF-17’s operational use during the May 2025 crisis (Operation Sindoor),” he stated.

**Contradictory Reports on Engine Sale**

Despite the expert’s comments, a senior Russian official denied any confirmation of the RD-93 engine supply deal to Pakistan. In a conversation with WION, the insider labeled the rumors as illogical, especially for those closely monitoring major defense deals between Russia and India. The source suggested that these reports might be driven by ulterior motives aimed at undermining promising cooperation ahead of high-level diplomatic contacts.

**Political Fallout in India**

The alleged deal has ignited political controversy within India. The opposition Congress party has criticized Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government for failing to prevent the sale of advanced RD-93 engines to Pakistan. Congress general secretary Jairam Ramesh questioned why Russia would continue offering military support to Pakistan while India is actively procuring sophisticated defense equipment like the S-400 missile systems and negotiating for the Su-57 stealth fighters from Moscow.

In response, the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) defended the government, dismissing the reports as “reckless information warfare.” BJP IT-cell head Amit Malviya cited Russia’s clarification on the matter and accused Congress leaders of making baseless accusations based on sources known for pro-Pakistan propaganda.

—

This developing story highlights the complex interplay of defense diplomacy, strategic interests, and political narratives shaping India-Russia-Pakistan relations. Further official updates are awaited to clarify the situation.
https://www.newsbytesapp.com/news/world/russian-expert-defends-rd-93-sale-to-pakistan/story